A virtual assessment of the suprainiac depressions on the Eyasi I (Tanzania) and Aduma ADU-VP-1/3 (Ethiopia) Pleistocene hominin crania
Introduction
The suprainiac fossa has been widely considered a Neanderthal-derived feature, described as a discrete elliptical depression with an uneven floor, confined to the area directly above inion, between the bilateral arches of the occipital torus (a prominent shelf-like structure between the supreme and superior nuchal lines; Hublin, 1978a, Hublin, 1978b, Hublin, 1983), with an apex on the midline (Hublin, 1978a, Hublin, 1984, Santa Luca, 1978, Stringer et al., 1984, Schwartz and Tattersall, 2005, Harvati et al., 2007, Harvati et al., 2019, Balzeau and Rougier, 2010, Nowaczewska, 2011, Franciscus and Holliday, 2013, Harvati, 2015, Nowaczewska et al., 2019). Initially described by Virchow (1872) as a pathological cranial feature on the Neanderthal holotype specimen, Feldhofer 1, it was later recognized by Klaatsch, 1902, Gorjanović-Kramberger, 1902, and Boule (1911–1913) as a nonpathological trait present on the Krapina (Croatia), Spy (Belgium), and La Chapelle-aux-Saints (France) Neanderthal crania. According to the accretion hypothesis (Dean et al., 1998, Hublin, 1998), which proposes the gradual establishment of specific Neanderthal craniofacial traits across four ‘stages’ of Neanderthal evolution (early pre-Neanderthals, pre-Neanderthals, early Neanderthals, and classic Neanderthals), the suprainiac fossa likely became fixed in the Neanderthal lineage. Some scholars consider the trait to be present in all Late Pleistocene European Neanderthals (e.g., Smith et al., 2005) and, in a less pronounced form, in Middle Pleistocene European specimens that are considered to be early members of the Neanderthal clade (Marston, 1937, Vandermeersch, 1978, Hublin, 1978a, Dean et al., 1998, Balzeau and Rougier, 2010, Arsuaga et al., 2014, Meyer et al., 2016).
Depressions above inion proposed as possibly homologous, or at least related, to the Neanderthal suprainiac fossa have been reported on several adult fossil human crania from the late Middle and Late Pleistocene of Africa (e.g., Haile-Selassie et al., 2004, Trinkaus, 2004, Balzeau and Rougier, 2010), the Late Pleistocene of Europe (e.g., Frayer, 1992, Kramer et al., 2001, Caspari, 2005, Soficaru et al., 2006, Soficaru et al., 2007, Trinkaus, 2007), the Late Pleistocene of the Levant (e.g., Skhūl V, Qafzeh VI, and Manot 1; Kramer et al., 2001, Smith et al., 2005, Hershkovitz et al., 2015, Hershkovitz et al., 2017), the Middle Pleistocene of China (Xuchang 2; Li et al., 2017), and the Late Pleistocene of Australia (e.g., Kow Swamp and Willandra Lakes; Thorne and Macumber, 1972, Wolpoff et al., 2001, Curnoe, 2011). Moreover, similar structures have been described for Holocene specimens from Europe, Africa, and Australia (Mirazón Lahr, 1994, Balzeau and Rougier, 2010, Nowaczewska, 2011, Nowaczewska et al., 2019).
Because of possible morphological similarities between the Neanderthal suprainiac fossae and some of these suprainiac depressions, the etiology and phylogenetic significance of these traits are the subject of continued discussion (e.g., Trinkaus, 2004, Caspari, 2005, Balzeau and Rougier, 2010, Bosman and Harvati, 2019, Nowaczewska et al., 2019). In particular, the presence of similar features on African Middle and Late Pleistocene hominins puts into question the status of the suprainiac fossa as a Neanderthal autapomorphy because the trait could possibly be inherited from the last common ancestor of modern humans and Neanderthals. Currently, however, only a handful of purported early Homo sapiens specimens from the African Middle and Late Pleistocene have been described as exhibiting a suprainiac depression. These include Eliye Springs KNM-ES 11693 (Bräuer and Leakey, 1986), Kébibat (Rabat) 1 (Saban, 1975), Eyasi I (Reck and Kohl-Larsen, 1936, Trinkaus, 2004), and ADU-VP-1/3 (Haile-Selassie et al., 2004). It should be noted that these specimens, with the exception of the Late Pleistocene ADU-VP-1/3 (Haile-Selassie et al., 2004, Yellen et al., 2005), are very poorly dated and can only be broadly placed within the Middle Pleistocene (Stearns and Thurber, 1965, Bräuer and Leakey, 1986, Mehlman, 1987, Domínguez-Rodrigo et al., 2008, Millard, 2008). As such, there is a limited understanding of the morphological variability in this time period.
To this end, we investigate here the proposed suprainiac depressions on the Eyasi I (Tanzania) and ADU-VP-1/3 (Ethiopia) specimens, maximizing the amount of information to be gained from these specimens through a systematic review of both their external and internal morphologies. These fossils are especially relevant for the common ancestry scenario as they date close to currently proposed time of appearance of modern human anatomical traits in eastern Africa (Eyasi I; 375–88 ka; Mehlman, 1987; Domínguez-Rodrigo et al., 2008) and to times of dispersal of anatomically modern humans out of Africa (ADU-VP-1/3; 105–79 ka; Yellen et al., 2005), respectively. Moreover, we focus on the internal morphology of the occipital squama (i.e., external table, diploic layer, and internal table) as recent research has shown that this can be especially informative in the distinction between Neanderthal suprainiac fossae and H. sapiens suprainiac depressions (Balzeau and Rougier, 2010, Balzeau and Rougier, 2013, Bosman and Harvati, 2019, Nowaczewska et al., 2019). Balzeau and Rougier (2010) found that the H. sapiens form of the suprainiac depression is characterized by significant bone remodeling and thinning restricted to the external table. In contrast, the Neanderthal form of the suprainiac depression is characterized by thinning of the diploic layer, whereas the external table exhibits no substantial remodeling and thinning (Balzeau and Rougier, 2010). These results suggest that the suprainiac fossa found in Neanderthals can be considered an autapomorphic (uniquely derived) trait.
If the depressions on Eyasi I and ADU-VP-1/3 are found to be quantitatively and qualitatively similar to the Neanderthal condition, then the status of the suprainiac fossa as a diagnostic Neanderthal autapomorphy must be reconsidered as it might be a homologous ancestral trait shared in the two lineages, thereby complicating the taxonomic assignment of isolated occipital bones in the fossil record. Alternatively, if the depressions above the inion on Eyasi I and ADU-VP-1/3 are found to differ from the Neanderthal condition, then the suprainiac fossa can be retained as an autapomorphic trait, and the common ancestry scenario should be reconsidered. Here, we explore these issues by performing a qualitative assessment of the external morphology of the putative suprainiac depressions and related occipital superstructures in Eyasi I and ADU-VP-1/3 as well as by making both qualitative and quantitative evaluations of their internal structure using microcomputed tomography (μCT). This is followed by a discussion on how our results inform the common ancestry hypothesis and the etiology of the suprainiac depression.
Section snippets
Materials and methods
In this study, we investigated the original Eyasi I and ADU-VP-1/3 fossils. The Eyasi hominin fossil assemblage was first discovered in 1935 by Ludwig and Margit Kohl-Larsen in the Westbucht (or West Bay) locality along the northeastern shore of Lake Eyasi, Tanzania (Reck and Kohl-Larsen, 1936, Kohl-Larsen, 1941, Kohl-Larsen, 1943). It comprises at least three individuals (Eyasi I–III) represented by fragmentary fossils recovered from the surface of the Lake Eyasi shore (Reck and Kohl-Larsen,
Results
Descriptions of the external morphology and internal characteristics of the suprainiac depressions for Eyasi I and ADU-VP-1/3 (Fig. 2a–b), in comparison with the condition exhibited by La Chapelle-aux-Saints 1 and La Ferrassie 1 (Fig. 2c-d), are provided in the following subsections and summarized in Table 2. The descriptions of the internal composition are based on the investigation of the entire CT data set, while orthogonal slices depict the depressions for every specimen (Fig. 3). Our
Variation in the supranuchal morphology of Eyasi I and ADU-VP-1/3
As already suggested by Trinkaus (2004), specific traits, such the weak occipital torus and the depression above inion, distinguish Eyasi I from most other African Middle Pleistocene fossils such as Broken Hill (Woodward, 1921), Bodo (Conroy et al., 1978), and Ndutu (Mturi, 1976). The presence of a suprainiac depression is also different from the morphology of other African early H. sapiens, including Ngaloba LH-18 (Day et al., 1980), Omo 2 (Day, 1969), and KNM-ER 3884 (Bräuer et al., 1992). A
Conclusions
This study presented a quantitative investigation of supranuchal depressions in two Middle/Late Pleistocene hominins, highlighting the benefit of applying virtual techniques in morphological analyses. The results suggest that the Eyasi I and ADU-VP-1/3 suprainiac depressions are not homologous to the Neanderthal suprainiac fossa but rather resemble the external and internal suprainiac morphology observed in recent modern H. sapiens. This implies that, when considering the internal structure of
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interest.
Acknowledgments
Support for this research was provided by the German Research Foundation (DFG FOR 2237: Project "Words, Bones, Genes, Tools: Tracking Linguistic, Cultural, and Biological Trajectories of the Human Past" and DFG INST 37/706-1 FUGG: Paleoanthropology High Resolution CT Laboratory). We thank Yonatan Sahle for suggesting the inclusion of ADU-VP-1/3 in this study, facilitating access to this specimen, and for comments on earlier versions of this manuscript. We thank the Middle Awash Project team, as
References (110)
- et al.
The Sima de los Huesos crania (Sierra de Atapuerca, Spain). A comparative study
J. Hum. Evol.
(1997) - et al.
Is the suprainiac fossa a Neandertal autapomorphy? A complementary external and internal investigation
J. Hum. Evol.
(2010) - et al.
The ES-11693 cranium from Eliye Springs, West Turkana, Kenya
J. Hum. Evol.
(1986) The Ndutu cranium and the origin of Homo sapiens
J. Hum. Evol.
(1990)- et al.
Late Stone Age human remains from Ishango (Democratic Republic of Congo): New insights on Late Pleistocene modern human diversity in Africa
J. Hum. Evol.
(2016) - et al.
On the phylogenetic position of the pre-Neandertal specimen from Reilingen, Germany
J. Hum. Evol.
(1998) - et al.
A new archaic Homo sapiens fossil from Lake Eyasi, Tanzania
J. Hum. Evol.
(2008) - et al.
A multi-method luminescence dating of the Palaeolithic sequence of La Ferrassie based on new excavations adjacent to the La Ferrassie 1 and 2 skeletons
J. Archeol. Sci.
(2015) - et al.
Cioclovina (Romania): affinities of an early modern European
J. Hum. Evol.
(2007) - et al.
Out of Africa and into the Levant: replacement or admixture in Western Asia?
Quat. Int.
(2001)
Archaic Homo sapiens at Lake Eyasi, Tanzania: Recent misrepresentations
J. Hum. Evol.
Provenience, age, and association of Archaic Homo sapiens crania from Lake Eyasi, Tanzania
J. Archeol. Sci.
A critique of the chronometric evidence for hominid fossils: I. Africa and the Near East 500–50ka
J. Hum. Evol.
Denisova admixture and the first modern human dispersals into southeast Asia and Oceania
Am. J. Hum. Genet.
A re-examination of presumed Neandertal-like fossils
J. Hum. Evol.
Earliest evidence for the structure of Homo sapiens populations in Africa
Quat. Sci. Rev.
Did our species evolve in subdivided populations across Africa, and why does it matter?
Trends Ecol. Evol.
The assimilation model, modern human origins in Europe, and the extinction of Neandertals
Quat. Int.
Th230/U234 dates of late Pleistocene marine fossils from the Mediterranean and Moroccan littorals
Prog. Oceanogr.
New age estimates for the Swanscombe hominid, and their significance for human evolution
J. Hum. Evol.
Neandertal roots: Cranial and chronological evidence from Sima de los Huesos
Science
New information on the modifications of the Neandertal suprainiac fossa during growth and development and on its etiology
Am. J. Phys. Anthropol.
A virtual assessment of the proposed suprainiac fossa on the early modern European calvaria from Cioclovina, Romania
Am. J. Phys. Anthropol.
L'Homme fossile de La Chapelle-aux-Saints
Ann. Paléontol.
Découverte d’un squelette humain moustérien à la Bouffia de la Chapelle-aux-Saints (Corrèze)
Anthropologie
Middle Pleistocene diversity in Africa and the origin of modern humans
New hominid fossil from Lake Eyasi, Tanzania
Anthropologie
A first report on the ER-3884 cranial remains from Ileret/east Turkana, Kenya
Pathological alterations in the archaic Homo sapiens cranium from Eliye Springs, Kenya
Am. J. Phys. Anthropol.
On the reliability of recent tests of the Out of Africa hypothesis for modern human origins
Anat. Rec.
Deux squelettes humains au milieu de foyers de l'époque moustérienne
Rev. Ecole Anthropol. Paris
Un nouveau squelette humain fossile
Rev. Anthropol.
Trois nouveaux squelettes humains fossiles
C. R. Séan. Acad. Inscriptions Belles-Lett.
The Human Lineage
The suprainiac fossa: the question of homology
Anthropologie (Brno)
extrafont: Tools for using fonts
Newly discovered fossil hominid skull from the Afar depression, Ethiopia
Nature
Modern human cranial diversity in the Late Pleistocene of Africa and Eurasia: Evidence from Nazlet Khater, Peştera cu Oase, and Hofmeyr
Am. J. Phys. Anthropol.
A 150-year conundrum: cranial robusticity and its bearing on the origin of Aboriginal Australians
Int. J. Evol. Biol.
Early Homo sapiens remains from the Omo River region of south-west Ethiopia: Omo human skeletal remains
Nature
A new hominid fossil skull (L.H. 18) from the Ngaloba Beds, Laetoli, northern Tanzania
Nature
Crossroads of the Old World
The persistence of Neanderthal features in post-Neanderthal Europeans
Der paläolithische Mensch und seine Zeitgenossen aus dem Diluvium von Krapina in Kroatien
Mitt. Anthropol. Ges. Wien
Electron spin resonance dating and the evolution of modern humans
Archaeometry
Early modern human diversity suggests subdivided population structure and a complex out-of-Africa scenario
Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA
Hominid cranial remains from upper pleistocene deposits at Aduma, Middle Awash, Ethiopia
Am. J. Phys. Anthropol.
Neanderthals and their contemporaries
The Later Stone Age calvaria from Iwo Eleru, Nigeria: morphology and chronology
PLoS One
Apidima Cave fossils provide earliest evidence of Homo sapiens in Eurasia
Nature
Cited by (5)
Investigating the internal structure of the suprainiac fossa in Xuchang 2
2023, Journal of Human EvolutionThree-dimensional geometric morphometric study of the Xuchang 2 cranium
2023, Journal of Human EvolutionMugharet el'Aliya: Affinities of an enigmatic north African Aterian maxillary fragment
2023, American Journal of Biological AnthropologyThe Hominin Fossil Record from Greece
2021, Fossil Vertebrates of Greece Vol. 1: Basal Vertebrates, Amphibians, Reptiles, Afrotherians, Glires, and PrimatesFrontal bone virtual reconstruction and geometric morphometric analysis of the mid-pleistocene hominin knm-og 45500 (Olorgesailie, kenya)
2020, Journal of Anthropological Sciences